THE ALCHEMYCAL PAGES
| The Human Being |Yin
& Yang |Disease of the Month|
The Ginger Compress| Food
and You | General Dietary Recommendations
|Disclaimer| Personal Information |]
MACROBIOTICS QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
WHAT IS MACROBIOTICS?
What is macrobiotics?
This is actually not an easy question to answer. It is easier
to say what it is not - it is not a medicine, it is not a cure,
it is not a diet, it is not a therapy, it is not a treatment.
The most important point to understand is that macrobiotics is
an approach to living which also places a great deal of emphasis
on a proper dietary practice in daily life. It is an approach
which is consistent with each person's natural biological and
ecological requirements to create optimal health, vitality and
well-being. It is a practical means of consciously re-establishing
balance in all aspects of an individual's life - physical, emotional,
mental, ecological, social and spiritual. If you are interested,
you can explore these pages, as well as other macrobiotically-related
Web sites, over the coming months, and more aspects of what a
macrobiotically oriented life will be explored.
What is the macrobiotic diet?
Actually, there is no such thing. Since macrobiotics is an approach
to eating and living, a person's dietary habits based on macrobiotic
principles will vary according to their physical condition, the
time of the year, in what kind of occupation they are engaged,
their level of physical activity, where they live etc.
Up until the advent of mass transportation methods, most people
in human history have eaten those foods which are native to their
locality. Thus, people living in the far northern climes did not
eat mangos, simply because mangos do not grow in, say, Minnesota.
In temperate climates, such as that of North America, people for
the most part ate cooked whole grains and vegetables, some nuts
and seeds, fruits and small amounts of animal food. Throughout
most of the world grains have been the staple, primary food of
human beings for thousands of years. Only during the last one
hundred years or so has humanity abandoned the "folk diet"
of their place of habitation and culture, replacing it with a
diet based on meat, refined sugar, large amounts of dairy food,
refined foods, and chemical, industrialized foodstuffs. This radical
abandonment of traditional, ecological dietary habits has been
accompanied by, and is the fundamental dynamic behind, the ensuing
rapid growth of social, economic, ecological and medical disorder
in the world, which we are witness to every time we open a newspaper,
watch a news program on TV, talk to our friends, relatives and
neighbors, or walk down the street.
Thus, macrobiotics is not an alternative to the modern practice
of medicine, or any other approach to addressing the ailments
and diseases of the day, whether they be personal, social or ecological.
Rather, macrobiotics is essentially the recovery and making conscious
of our folklore and native, traditional wisdom, brought up to
date and taking into consideration what we have learnt in the
materialistic, scientific era.
What kinds of food can I eat on a macrobiotic diet?
Actually, when people are told what they should avoid to become
healthier, they usually ask, "Well, what can I eat?".
For people living in North America, generally speaking, a diet
consisting of cooked whole grains, vegetables, beans and bean
products, sea vegetables, and soups is normal. Ideally, these
foods should be seasonal and locally grown, organically or bio-dynamically.
For optimal health, a variety of cooking methods are employed
to produce a variety of tastes, textures, nutrition and vitality.
When beginning a macrobiotic dietary practice it is recommended
to consult with a macrobiotic counsellor, especially if you are
confused and intimidated by the array of strange names and new
foods that are encountered on beginning a macrobiotic play.
Isn't the "ultimate" macrobiotic diet eating only brown
No, like many unfamiliar subjects, misconceptions about macrobiotics
abound. For almost everyone, a healthy diet is one that includes
a wide variety of foods, prepared in a variety of ways.
Will macrobiotics cure serious illness?
There is, in my view, no cure for any disease(the problem of curing
disease is explored in more detail in the Introduction
Page). Rather, any disease is the constellation of symptoms
produced by the body when a person lives an imbalanced, unhealthy
way of life. Any disease almost always takes a long time to develop,
usually in conjunction with improper nutritional intake and poor
bodily elimination. If these are changed to proper, dynamically
balanced eating habits, and clearing of the poor eliminative functions
of the body, then the body can begin to heal itself.
It is not claimed that a macrobiotic diet can cure any illness.
However, a return to a grain-centered diet and a strong personal
commitment to health establishes a possibility for healing any
condition that would not otherwise exist. Many people with many
degenerative illnesses, including AIDS, cancer, lupus, multiple
sclerosis, arthritis, asthma, chronic fatigue syndrome, to name
a few, have used a macrobiotic approach for their condition, and
have subsequently experienced dramatic improvements in their lives,
and even a disappearance of their symptoms. There is no doubt
that a macrobiotic approach allows for a revitalisation and restoration
of health that might not otherwise be possible.
I am already healthy. Will a macrobiotic diet benefit me?
Definitely. The best time to begin a macrobiotic approach to dietary
habits is when we are relatively healthy. You will experience
significant and beneficial results. Most people undergo dramatic
weight loss if they are overweight, increase in vitality, disappearance
of everyday aches and pains, and develop a feeling of calm and
emotional stability. Also people find improvements in their mental
functions, hearing, eyesight, and in women, the female cycle undergoes
Are the nutrient requirements of the child or adult met by a macrobiotic
Without a doubt. The so-called "standard dietary recommendation"
of a macrobiotic approach have been analysed at the School of
Public Health at Harvard University. The results showed that the
diet actually exceeded in every respect the recommended daily
allowances of both the FDA and the World Health Organisation.
Thus, there is no concern about having to take extra vitamins
or trace mineral supplements. Futhermore, from a macrobiotic perspective,
it is not desirable for the body to intake artificial, refined
or concentrated vitamin or mineral supplements. It is thought
these actively interfere with the proper biological functions
of minerals and vitamins founds in their natural surroundings
of grains and vegetables, beans and sea vegetables.
Can I eat meat and still follow a macrobiotic diet?
The whole question of what we can eat does not presuppose that
some foods are bad and some foods are good. The only foods considered
to be unacceptable for human beings are synthetic chemicals and
all those foods that contain chemicals or which are highly industrialised.
The fact remains, however, that the regular consumption of animal-based
foodstuffs actively contributes to degeneration of the physical
body. Generally, as people continue on a macrobiotic diet and
experience improvement in their health, they tend to refrain from
or only occasionally eat animal foods.
Is macrobiotic food dull?
Not at all. When properly prepared, macrobiotic food is delicious
and satisfying. Many people initially find the diet somewhat bland.
However, as their health improves and as their taste buds get
acclimatised to the new foods, they come to appreciate the subtle
and delicious taste of natural foods. Removing strong spices and
the intensely concentrated refined sugars, chemicals and additives
abounding in modern foods allows for the experience of the distinctive
flavours found in grains, beans and vegetables.
Is macrobiotic cooking time-consuming?
This is an erroneous assumption many people make on first encountering
macrobiotics. When beginning to learn how to cook macrobiotically
it is neccessary to unlearn some old cooking habits, and learn
new cooking skills. It is important, and actually a significant
aspect of the healing process, to learn how to cook macrobiotically,
and to to do your own cooking. This learning process will enhance
your appreciation of food, and increase its value for yourself,
your family and your friends.
In the beginning, food preparation may take longer than when you
were eating a conventional diet. But in a relatively short time
you can learn to efficiently prepare your meals. If you live in
an area where macrobiotic cooking classes are available, it is
well worth your time and effort to take some classes.
Is a macrobiotic diet mostly Japanese food?
No. The people who brought macrobiotics to, and are the 'pioneers'
of macrobiotic teaching and practice in, the United States, are
Japanese. It is not surprising, then, that they brought many aspects
of the Japanese culinary tradition with them. Consequently, until
quite recently most macrobiotic diets and cookbooks emphasised
traditional Japanese foods and cooking styles. For Americans,
though, the health promoting foods are those native to the American
climate and soil. As macrobiotic principles and practice become
more widespread on the North American continent, then we can expect
a revitalisation and rediscovery of native american culinary traditions,
as well as the culinary traditions of different ethnic groups
whose place of origin are distant from the North American continent.
Is a macrobiotic diet expensive?
On the contrary, it is a very economical way of eating and staying
healthy. Generally, you can expect to reduce your food bills from
30% to 50% by switching from a conventional diet to a macrobiotic
diet. And if you include the savings in medical costs because
of enhanced health and well-being resulting from adopting a macrobiotic
diet, the savings are multiplied many times over.
How quickly will I see results?
As soon as you begin to properly nurture your body it responds
with a more positive state of health. Your overall health is greatly
determined by the quality of your blood, which, in turn, is largely
determined by the quality of the food you eat. The food is converted
into blood-blood which is the "organ" of nourishment
and regulation of the functions of the organs and tissues of the
As the quality of your blood improves, health improves. It normally
takes ten days for the plasma to recycle, so improvements begin
to be noticeable after ten days. It takes 30 days for the white
blood cells to renew, so immune function begins to improve after
a month. It takes 120 days for the red blood cells to be renewed,
so it is only then that true healing can begin.
Now, although improvement of health generally does occur, it may
not necessarily be a smooth transition from a poor physical condition
to a healthy one. During the early stages of the healing process,
various "discharges" or detoxifying symptoms occur,
which are similar to symptoms usually associated with sickness.
Generally everybody experiences increased urination and bowel
movement, as well as weight loss. In addition to these signs,
the symptoms of the body healing itself include fevers, headaches,
flu-like symptoms, fatigue, nasal mucous discharge, sore throats,
coughing and sneezing, diarrhoea, skin eruptions and, in the case
of women, vaginal discharge and cystitis-like symptoms. The question
then arises, how do you know the symptoms you are experiencing
indicate your body is healing rather than you are in fact becoming
sick? There are four cardinal signs to be aware of which will
enable you to tell the difference. These are appetite, vitality,
sleep patterns and nausea.
In the case of someone becoming sick, then all four signs are
negative. That is, you have no appetite, no vitality, your sleep
patterns are disturbed and you feel sick. In the case where your
body is undergoing detoxification, then one, two or even three
of these signs may be present, but very rarely all four. It is
advisable that you are in contact with a macrobiotic counselor,
or you are in touch with an active macrobiotic community, who
you can talk to about these symptoms and advise you what to do
about them, if and when they occur.
For those who begin a macrobiotic practice with serious illnesses,
it must be remembered that the illness took several years, or
even decades, to develop. After adopting a macrobiotic approach
to health you may experience immediate benefits, but generally
a complete recovery takes time and requires patience. It may take
from one to several years for complete recovery to occur, depending
on the illness, and such factors as your age, your general overall
health status, and other individual considerations.
Are there any scientific studies about macrobiotic diets and health?
In recent years there has been a tremendous increase in the study
of nutrition and its relationship to health. Whereas, even as
short a time as ten years ago, most authorities on medicine and
health completely ruled out diet as having anything to do with
health or disease. Most of the studies have been put together
in encapsulated form by Alex Jack, in his recent book, "Let
Food be Your Medicine" (One Peaceful World Publications,
1992), which is a compilation of about 165 studies done by the
scientific community on macrobiotic and vegetarian diets. These
studies confirm the benefits of macrobiotic principles and practices.
Can I take it step-by-step or do I need to "go for it"?
If your health is relatively good, you can go either way. It is
important that you start a macrobiotic practice in a way that
suits your personality and temperament. Generally speaking, though,
the sooner you can be fully on a macrobiotic diet, the better.
In case of serious illness, one should definitely begin the diet
fully and completely as soon as possible.
How long do I have to remain on a macrobiotic diet before I can
The problem here is the implication in the question that somehow
a macrobiotic diet is a cure for illness. However, as stated earlier,
there is no cure for any illness. A macrobiotic approach to eating
is essentially flexible depending on your condition. To adopt
a macrobiotic approach to eating means you understand that cooked
whole grains and vegetables are your staple foods for the rest
of your life. Your commitment to your own health and well-being
means you can adjust your dietary intake to your situation and
changing circumstances, but being able to do this means a study
of the principles behind macrobiotic practice is necessary.
I want to lose weight. Will I on a macrobiotic diet?
Generally, weight loss is the normal response for those people
who are overweight after starting their macrobiotic practice.
People with severe weight problems will, of course, take longer
to lose all their excess weight.
I am already thin enough. Will I also lose weight?
Since a macrobiotic approach to eating is based on a principle
of balance, many times people who are underweight actually gain
weight on a similar diet to a person who is overweight loses weight.
However, any person adopting a grain based diet will have difficulty,
in the initial stages, digesting the grains and vegetables properly.
Thus, most people lose whatever weight they need to lose, up to
about five pounds under what their weight will stabilise to on
a grain and vegetable diet. It is accurate to say that most people
eating a macrobiotic diet are thin compared to the cultural (high
fat and refined foods) norm. However, whatever weight loss occurs
is usually optimal, and not indicative of disease.
Should children and adults eat the same macrobiotic diet?
The nutritional needs of growing children are somewhat different
than those of adults. Since the the macrobiotic approach to diet
is that each individual should eat according to their individual
needs, a child's macrobiotic diet will differ from the normal
adult's. These differences are easily addressed in the course
of preparing the family meal.
Isn't a lot of salt used in macrobiotic cooking? I've heard that
too much salt is unhealthy.
Too much of any food is unhealthy. In appropriate amounts, salt
is essential for maintaining the body's electrolyte and mineral
balance. The salt used in the normal American diet is 98% sodium
chloride and is stripped of vital trace elements. This refined
salt, eaten with large amounts of animal fat and protein is implicated
in many of the degenerative diseases that plague people today.
The salt recommended for use in a macrobiotic diet is sea salt,
containing less sodium chloride and an abundance of natural trace
minerals such as magnesium, zinc and copper. Used in proper amounts,
this natural sea salt is essential for good health.
Are there any books I can read to help me understand macrobiotics?
There is a plethora of books available, and it is essential to
gain an understanding of macrobiotic principles and concepts in
order to really benefit from a macrobiotic practice. Since you
are a unique individual, only you can know and decide what is
the best way for you to eat. Also, since you and your condition
changes over time, you need to make subtle and not so subtle changes
in your eating habits, depending on how long you have been eating
macrobiotically, what season it is, what climatic variations occur
in your place of habitation, what the weather is like, what kind
of lifestyle you have, and other individual variations.
I recommend the following books and publications:
Laughing with Doomsday - Kaare Bursell.
The End of Medicine - Kaare Bursell.
Philosophy of Oriental Medicine-George Ohsawa(GOMF).
Zen Macrobiotics-George Ohsawa(GOMF).
Guidebook for Living-George Ohsawa(GOMF).
The Macrobiotic Way-Michio Kushi(Avery Publications).
Book of Do-In-Michio Kushi(Japan Publications).
Healing Ourselves-Naboru Muramoto(Avon Books).
Basic Macrobiotics-Herman Aihara(Japan Publications).
Cooking for Regeneration-Cecile Tovah Levin(Japan Publications).
Self-Healing Cookbook-Kristine Turner(Earthtone Books).
Food and Healing-Anne Marie Colbin(Ballantine).
Also, I recommend subscribing to "Macrobiotics Times",
published monthly. See "Resources" on how to obtain
Comments or questions can be sent to the address below as I check
this address every few weeks. Please mention Alchemycal Pages in the
subject line. Thank you. Patricia
Copyright © Kaare Bursell, 1996-2031.